I tried to recreate your problem and I couldn´t.
In native files a good solution is to copy the surface and the use the thicken command.
On imported files the Project/Loop is also a fast solution.
You can even use udf´s or mapkeys to speed up the process.
Watch my short video, maybe it can help you.
Attention:You will need to update your browsers Flash Player plugin to see videos on this site.
Jose